How to Choose Between Thumbport I and Thumbport II: A Guide for Flutists
Flutists of all levels know that holding the flute properly is crucial—not only for comfort and technique but also for preventing long-term injuries. Enter the Thumbport, an innovative accessory designed to stabilize the flute and reduce strain on the hands. But with two models available—Thumbport I and Thumbport II—you might be wondering: which one is right for me?
Let’s explore the origins of the Thumbport, what makes each model unique, and how to choose the one that best suits your playing needs.
The Story Behind the Thumbport
The Thumbport was born out of necessity and experience. Its creator, Ho-Fan Lee, began playing flute as a young student in Taiwan. He suffered a significant injury to his right pinky due to over-practicing, which affected his flute playing for years. When studying under William Bennett at the Royal Academy of Music, Lee learned about the three-point balance system—a way to hold the flute using only the chin, left index finger, and right thumb. This approach, especially when the thumb supports the flute from a diagonal angle (30°–45°), reduces stress on the fingers and encourages a more efficient hand position.
Later, inspired by lessons from Michel Debost and the stability-focused Thumbalina, Lee created the Thumbport—a tool that helps flutists achieve better hand positioning, stability, and comfort.
Thumbport I vs. Thumbport II: What's the Difference?
Both versions of the Thumbport aim to support better flute posture and reduce strain—but they differ in design and feel. Here's a breakdown to help you compare:
Feature |
Thumbport |
Thumbport II |
Thumb angle |
Higher default angle |
Lower default angle |
Contact with flute |
More surface contact |
Less contact (easier for smaller hands) |
Rigidity |
Slightly more flexible |
More rigid and stable |
Extension arm |
Longer |
Shorter (fits more easily into cases) |
Edge design |
Flatter |
More rounded for comfort |
Fit in case |
May require removal depending on placement |
Often fits better due to the shorter profile |
Adjustability |
Less customizable |
Easier to trim and modify the angle |
Leave a comment